Aragón is home to dozens of announced data centre projects, whose full impact on energy, water, and land use has not yet been fully assessed. This article aims to contribute to that assessment from an independent perspective.
Within the framework of an event hosted by the European Urban Initiative in Fundão (Portugal), I had the opportunity some months ago to present the challenge that Aragon faces in the wake of a wave of data centre projects across its territory. Although framed for illustrative purposes around Aragon, the logic applies to many other regions: the data centre phenomenon is global.
The proliferation of data centres is one of the most visible consequences of the digitalisation of our society — a process that began nearly 100 years ago with the invention of the transistor and has only accelerated since.
The explosion of Big Data first, and then Artificial Intelligence — the latter impossible without the former — has not only changed the way we relate to machines and to each other, but has also begun to leave a deep mark on the landscape in the form of enormous architectural boxes.
Data centres are also a consequence of the transition to a service economy. Before the arrival of the “cloud”, companies stored their data and software on servers housed on their own premises, maintained — in their mechanical, electrical and IT aspects — by in-house staff. Today, data centres contain that “cloud” of atoms, volts and bits that serves both large corporations and small businesses alike.
Are Data Centres a Knowledge Economy or an Extractive Economy?
Artificial Intelligence consumes data to train its models, materials and energy to power its vast electronic circuitry, and water to cool it. It also requires large areas of land on which to build data centres, and talent to design and programme the algorithms.
Data, materials, energy, water, land and talent are therefore the “inputs” needed for AI to produce the services that, if the numbers add up, will drive our society to previously unimaginable levels of development and wellbeing.
Of the six “nutrients” of AI, three are tied to place — energy, water and land — while data and talent can be applied remotely. Materials, meanwhile, travel through logistics chains. This division is what allows data centres to be delocalised away from R&D hubs.
In talent hubs, AI thus contributes to the knowledge economy. In territories that primarily supply energy, water and land, data centres are an extractive economy — like mines, or like farms.
Data Centres and Electricity Demand in Aragon: How Many TWh?
The challenge that data centres pose for the territory extends to energy. Two magnitudes are at stake: contracted power — the maximum power the grid can supply at any given moment, measured in watts, kilowatts, megawatts or gigawatts — and consumption over time, measured in kilowatt-hours (kWh), megawatt-hours (MWh), gigawatt-hours (GWh), and so on.
Data centre consumption is on the order of terawatt-hours (TWh). To put that in context: a city of 700,000 inhabitants like Zaragoza consumes around 3 TWh per year.
No fewer than 20 data centre projects have been announced in Aragon to date, some of which — from Amazon Web Services (AWS) and Microsoft, for example — are already under way. Together, projected consumption could exceed 20 TWh per year.
Since Aragon’s total electricity consumption currently stands at around 10 TWh per year, we are talking about tripling it — from 10 TWh to 30 TWh annually — and that under a conservative scenario.
Aragon currently produces around 22 TWh of energy per year, half of which it consumes. Meeting the projected demand from its own sources would require either a major increase in production — with the associated landscape and investment implications — or importing energy from elsewhere.
In the latter case, Aragon’s net electricity balance would flip entirely. Currently a net exporter — selling roughly half of what it produces — it would become a net importer once the announced data centres came online.
The Logistics of Energy
The energy challenges do not end there. Energy is not automatically available at any point on the territory; it must be transported from its point of production to its point of consumption. The electricity grid — cables and transformer substations — performs that logistical function.
In Spain, it is Redeia (formerly Red Eléctrica Española, REE) that transports electricity and must manage, through multi-year energy planning, the inevitable territorial tensions arising from imbalances between production and consumption zones.
Under the national 2026–2030 plan presented last September, the total power capacity allocated to Aragon for data centres stands at 4.5 GW — higher than the most optimistic demand scenario of 3.5 GW (according to a study by the Fundación Basilio Paraíso backed by the Government of Aragon. On these figures, Aragon would retain a margin of 1 GW to accommodate new technology projects through to 2030.
Zero-Mile Electricity
Just as we would not plug every appliance in our home into the same socket, a degree of geographic distribution of data centres across the electricity grid makes sense. The main concerns raised by the Government of Aragon relate to insufficient capacity on the metropolitan ring around Zaragoza.
To minimise the political and technical challenges of energy transmission, some data centres are beginning to opt for “zero-mile” electrons. This very week, President Azcón, together with Forestalia executives, presented the “Búfalo” project — three data centres designed to source 50% of their energy from the company’s own renewable assets in the region.
However, deploying wind and solar farms involves not only landscape impact but also significant land take. Serving a dense cluster of data centres with extensive wind and solar parks has its limits. In all likelihood, the proliferation will also entail recourse to other energy sources.
Data Centres and Nuclear Energy
In Virginia — one of the highest-density data centre areas in the world — Microsoft has reached an agreement with nuclear operator Constellation Energy to reopen the Three Mile Island reactor from 2027, facilitated by a $1 billion government credit under the Trump administration.
Beyond Microsoft, Google and AWS are investing in nuclear energy companies and in Small Modular Reactors (SMRs) to power their data centres. These giants describe nuclear energy as “clean energy”, ideal for a “carbon-free” future (the inverted commas signal the ongoing controversy around nuclear’s environmental credentials).
All of these energy investments — in production, transmission or transformation — are ultimately passed on to consumers. Back in Virginia, rising electricity tariffs driven by data centre proliferation sparked a wave of public anger that influenced recent state elections. The newly elected Governor, Abigail Spanberger, has pledged to make the data centre industry bear the cost of price increases.
Water Consumption of Data Centres in Aragon
Cooling processes in data centres accelerate when ambient temperatures exceed 29°C — something that in the Zaragoza area, where data centre projects are concentrated, is happening with increasing frequency. Unfortunate timing: data centres grow thirsty at the same moment as agriculture and people.
As the ECODES Foundation notes in its [report on the water impact of data centres](https://ecodes.org/hacemos/cambio-climatico/consumo-de-agua-por-los-centros-de-datos), lack of transparency about water consumption makes precise assessment of their water footprint difficult. It is nonetheless worth providing at least an order of magnitude. To do so, we can estimate water consumption based on two assumptions:
– that the consumption figures provided by AWS to the Government of Aragon in the PIGA (Project of General Interest for Aragon) documentation are accurate
– that the remaining data centres are at least as water-efficient as AWS
To estimate water use, we need a conversion factor in litres per kilowatt-hour: the WUE (Water Usage Effectiveness), defined as annual water consumption (litres) divided by energy consumed (kWh). In practice, data centres that use evaporative cooling (such as those of AWS) have a relatively high WUE of 0.2–1.5 L/kWh — in exchange for greater energy efficiency — while those that cool via closed-circuit air systems (Microsoft) have a very low WUE, at the cost of higher energy consumption.
Using a WUE of 0.5 L/kWh — at the low end of the range for the technology employed by AWS — the water requirements of all data centres announced up to August 2025 come to around 10 million cubic metres per year, based on total projected energy consumption of around 20 TWh.
Data Centres and Water Scarcity: Aragon vs Virginia
That water consumption is comparable to that of around 250,000 households (Spain’s INE estimates average household water consumption at 40.15 cubic metres per year), or to the irrigation needs of around 2,200 hectares of farmland.
Returning to Virginia — the “mecca” of data centres — average annual rainfall there is around 1,200 litres per square metre, while Zaragoza receives barely a quarter of that (320 l/m²). This context helps explain why the ECODES report warns of the risk of conflict between data centres and local communities over priority water use. In Aragon, as local politicians know well, debates over water are no small matter.
That said, the sector will have no choice but to comply with the new transparency requirements imposed by the European Commission and transposed into Spanish law. Each May, data centres must report their consumption to a European database, which will allow for rigorous study of their water and energy footprint.
Over time, this mandatory transparency will build up a historical dataset capable of sustaining rigorous analysis of the environmental impact of data centres. Until then, it seems unwise to rush to fill Aragon’s territory with projects that are difficult to reverse.
Towards a Possible Moratorium: The Catalan Example of Intensive Pig Farming
In the case of data centres, waiting does not necessarily mean missing the train of progress — it may mean avoiding missing the train of quality of life. It would not be the first or last area where a moratorium has been proposed.
For some years now, neighbouring Catalonia has maintained a de facto moratorium on new intensive livestock projects. With 41% of Catalan aquifers contaminated by nitrates in 2016, and amid persistent drought episodes, the Catalan government approved Decree 153/2019 on soil fertilisation management and livestock waste, establishing a moratorium on new farms and on the expansion of existing ones.
In Aragon, by contrast, the absence of regulatory hurdles and lower social opposition have acted as a pull factor for investment and sector growth — often driven by Catalan companies such as the well-known Bonárea.
The result: in 2010, Catalonia had 7 million pigs, compared to 3.8 million in Aragon. The latest 2024 figures show a reversal: while Catalonia has stabilised its herd (7.8 million head), Aragon has seen it surge to 15 million, generating an estimated economic output of €2.5 billion per year.
For those who feel that comparing data centres to intensive pig farms is an exaggeration, or that such a comparison undervalues a high-tech investment, we would suggest reflecting on the following question: other than abundant land and cheap energy, on what high-technology factors do the data centres announced in Escatrón, Calatorao, Cariñena, Luceni, Magallón, Botorrita or Alfamén actually rely?
To understand this paradox, we must return, once again, to Virginia.
Virginia: It All Started with a Neutral Node
A neutral node (Internet Exchange Point, IXP) is a point of interconnection for the internet — where the traffic of the network of networks is exchanged. For high-technology companies, being located near a neutral node confers a competitive advantage, since their internet traffic travels faster than that of competitors relying on hundreds of kilometres of high-capacity fibre optic cable.
Aragon has no neutral nodes. The nearest ones are hundreds of kilometres away, in Madrid, Barcelona or Bilbao. Virginia, however, established MAE-East in 1992 — one of the world’s principal non-governmental neutral exchange points. Since then, Virginia has become the primary internet exchange hub on the US East Coast.
From there, the need for connectivity attracted the first Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to the area, which in turn drew in data centres with computing capacity for low-latency applications such as stock trading, online gaming and interactive audiovisual content. Virginia is not merely well connected to the internet: it *is* the internet.
Beyond other factors such as proximity to the government machinery of Washington D.C. and the availability of venture capital, the ingredients that made Virginia a technology ecosystem were — in order — interconnection (neutral nodes), the arrival of high-tech companies with compelling applications, and data centres providing high cloud computing capacity.
Can Data Centres Create a Technology Ecosystem in Aragon?
Few politicians understand how innovation ecosystems actually work. If ten years ago Silicon Valley was trivialised — every technology park was going to be the “next Silicon Valley” — today the concept of ecosystem is being similarly banished. Ecosystems are not announced, created, or directed. At most they can be encouraged, facilitated and accompanied. And from institutions, as one ecosystem actor among many, one can participate in them and contribute to them.
It will be difficult — though not impossible — for the data centre in the photograph, in Villanueva de Gállego, to ever become part of an innovation ecosystem: one where universities engage in its development, where start-ups nurtured by seed capital flourish around it, where AWS engineers develop new cloud-based public services alongside those of regional institutions.
Not to mention the public space — could there be a harsher territorial setting? — or the housing, of which nothing is said in any of the announced projects, or the taxes, which are withheld from the municipalities hosting data centres by virtue of the PIGA instrument, making it harder for them to reinvest in improving their communities.
And it is precisely of places — but also of water, development and landscape — that an old song by the Aragonese group La Bullonera spoke. After evoking the Monegros, its water, its crops and its harshness, it ended:
“…of this beautiful land,
*harsh and wild,*
we will make a place.
And a landscape.”
That is what this is about: ensuring that data centres help build an ecosystem, without leaving an environmental or landscape footprint that we cannot afford. Making a place, in short, without unmaking a landscape.
—
Article published under a Creative Commons free culture licence of type CC BY-SA 4.0. Some rights reserved.